City vs. rural routes: Is one better than the other?
Key Highlights
- Metro routes reduce travel distances but often have more competing dealers and tool retailers.
- Dense traffic, limited parking, and short shop hours can make metro servicing difficult.
- Rural routes involve more miles, weather risks, and longer days between smaller shops.
- Smaller communities may have less competition and strong demand from industrial, agricultural, and heavy-equipment customers.
- Across both markets, exceptional and consistent customer service is the key to a successful route.
I wish I had that route." I've heard that more times than I can count over the years. The idea that one route is better than another, for the most part, is simply a myth. I've known a number of dealers over the years who have changed flags and/or routes. The one constant? They all remained successful no matter the area or the logo on the side of the truck.
I myself have been with three different flags in two different rural areas. While it may be true that some routes have industries such as oil fields, mining, shipping ports, etc., that in no way makes one area better than the next. The bottom line is, if you provide subpar service, you'll experience subpar success. With that, are there advantages and disadvantages to routes in larger metro areas versus mostly rural areas?
Metro routes: More customers, more competition
Metro routes definitely have the advantage of a large customer base in a smaller footprint. In some cases, it's possible to remain within a couple of blocks for the majority of the week. Obviously, working in a small area is going to greatly reduce fuel and some maintenance costs.
Today's tool trucks do not have the heavy battery drain of ballast-style showroom lighting. In the "old days," it was common practice to start your truck in the morning and keep it running until you've arrived back home that night. LED lighting reduces the load on the "house batteries," making it possible to shut off the truck while servicing a shop. Still, there's enough electrical load to trip the inverter in less than a half hour.
Newer diesel trucks with DEF systems don't do well with prolonged idling. It will plug the particulate filters in a short amount of time. That makes running an accessory generator necessary. Although running a generator uses less fuel, there is the extra cost of the generator itself and the additional maintenance of another power source.
While there are more customers in a smaller area, the amount of competition is far greater. Metro areas usually have representation from all four flags. Along with the franchise trucks, there's usually at least one independent tool truck. Having five-plus dealers servicing the same base not only makes tool sales more competitive, but it also makes collections more challenging. There's no way the average technician could afford to carry even a modest balance on so many trucks. The only way to be the dealer with the highest collections is to also be the dealer with the biggest commitment to premium customer service.
Not only does the dense population warrant more tool trucks, but the number of brick-and-mortar stores selling tools also increases. Parts stores are becoming increasingly aggressive in marketing tools and equipment. There's also a larger variety of specialty discount tool stores, home centers, and hardware stores.
Dense traffic and large tool trucks increase the chance of collisions. Parking is sometimes nonexistent. Double parking in a lane of traffic becomes the norm. Maneuvering a large truck in mega dealerships and business complexes makes fender benders more likely. It's not uncommon to get back to your truck only to find you've been boxed in by other vendors or customer vehicles.
Your drive time is measured in minutes as opposed to the number of miles between shops. There's a smaller window of shop hours. Most businesses only operate during the normal 8 to 5.
Rural routes: More miles, longer days
Rural routes increase the number of miles between customers compared to metro routes by a wide margin. Depending on where you live, road conditions can sometimes be the biggest challenge of the day.
I had routes in eastern and central Oregon. Both parts of the state are known for hazardous winter travel. I had years of dense fog, freezing rain, whiteouts, and snow coming down faster than the road plows could keep up with. I had automatic tire chains installed on my last two trucks.
It's important to protect yourself and your investment. Had I had better sense, there were plenty of times I should have stayed home rather than take a chance on the road conditions. All it takes is another vehicle to slide through an icy intersection, and your truck is out of service.
It's not as likely to have all four flags servicing smaller communities. A rural area sometimes takes two, three, or more small towns to support the 300-plus customers needed to fill a route. Because of the lack of population, there's not a large amount of competition from other retail stores dealing in tools.
My last route consisted of three days in my hometown, one day servicing a small town to the north, and one day in another small town to the east. Both were approximately a 30-mile drive.
The biggest challenge is fitting in all the shops in a day. I was arriving at my first stop at 5:30 a.m. and seldom left the last shop before 6:30 p.m. Tool truck days are already long, but out-of-town days are even longer. You call on a lot of one- or two-tech shops. You're not seeing as many techs per hour compared to metro areas. Fewer customers per hour usually equates to longer days.
The small communities I serviced were heavy with industrial, agriculture, and heavy equipment. They are usually good-paying jobs with steady work and not a lot of turnover.
What really makes a route successful?
The primary factor in what makes a route exceptional is an exceptional dealer. It has very little to do with servicing a large city or a rural area. Both markets have plenty of customers with tool and tool storage needs.
Every week when you walk into a shop, you are really interviewing for the job of tool dealer. Getting hired is up to you and the level of exceptional customer service you consistently provide.
About the Author
Brian FahlgrenBrian Fahlgren
Brian Fahlgren started in the tool business in 1998. Fahlgren has been an employee dealer, franchised dealer, and district manager for two different flags. In 2018, he returned to the driver's seat of his own tool truck. Providing premium service and his continuous "close to perfect" attitude, he achieved his goal of being a Top 10 dealer for Cornwell Quality Tools. He and his wife of over 44 years recently retired, moving from Oregon to the endless summers of Beverly Hills, Florida.
Related
Cornwell Quality Tools Distributor Elias Valdovinos


